Massachusetts and Connecticut invested millions into offshore wind in the hopes the once-blossoming industry would jump-start local economies. But amid Trump’s multifront war on the industry, workers say they’re watching opportunity dry up.
On a hot July day in 2022, then-President Joe Biden gave a speech from the ruins of a coal-fired power plant on the southern coast of Massachusetts.
Standing where ships once delivered coal for combustion, he said the same dock would soon launch components for wind power out to sea.
He praised an Italian company’s plans to build a new factory there, set to create 250 jobs and supply American-made undersea power cables to what was then a line of offshore wind projects waiting to be built along the coast.
Four years later, weeds and tall grass have reclaimed the dirt lot on which Biden spoke.
The company never came.
A 20-minute drive east, in New Bedford, hundreds of workers who helped assemble wind turbine parts from Canada and Europe over the last three years have given way to seagulls and geese. The birds shuffle along the now-empty pier the state of Massachusetts spent $140 million to build for offshore wind development.
In nearby Providence, Rhode Island, a newly built factory that manufactured offshore wind turbine foundation platforms has emptied out.
Amid the Trump administration’s multifront war against offshore wind, the cost on the ground in New England, the launchpad of the country’s offshore wind industry, can be seen in empty warehouses, silent marine terminals and ledgers recording hundreds of millions of dollars of state investment that may not be recouped.
ProPublica partnered with Ocean State Media, The Connecticut Mirror and the New Bedford Light to document the consequences of the administration’s efforts.
Many offshore wind projects faced a precarious future before President Donald Trump retook office. Rising construction costs driven by inflation and supply chain shortages forced some developers to back out of contracts to build wind farms and supply electricity to states. Various groups have also fought construction of projects saying they disrupt marine ecosystems and mar coastal views.
But last year, the administration temporarily forced five projects to stop construction, further clouding the horizon. Courts allowed the developers to proceed, but that has not eliminated the threat. Last month, the U.S. Department of the Interior asked a court for permission to reconsider a key permit for one of those five projects, Revolution Wind, which is already up and running and can power more than 350,000 New England homes at maximum capacity.
The administration also has frozen future development on all offshore wind farms, including a cluster of projects that haven’t been built but proposed to power up to 1.7 million New England homes. It has blocked or is seeking review of the permits that would allow these to be built. Meanwhile, the administration is paying other wind developers billions of dollars to sell back their leases and walk away.
At a press conference Monday, Trump said he supports a bipartisan bill that would accelerate U.S. energy development. When a reporter pointed out that the bill includes wind energy, Trump said he would not approve “wind turbines ’cause wind turbines are a major loser.”
The upheaval has had ripple effects. The cable company Biden touted decided not to build its factory, citing “long-term trends in the U.S. market.”
Port cities like New Bedford, Massachusetts, and New London, Connecticut, are left trying to hold onto the economic gains they have made building wind farms.
As recently as last winter, New Bedford, a historic whaling and textile manufacturing center, had hotels, offices and piers buzzing with offshore wind workers. Local businesses from caterers to cleaners to fuel suppliers landed new contracts servicing the wind industry.
In New London — another port once central to the whaling industry — officials worked with one of the world’s largest wind developers to pump more than $300 million of public and private funds into a state-owned pier. Despite significant cost overruns and some early construction challenges, the effort transformed the pier into a staging area for the wind industry.
Over the last four years, the pier has been a hive of activity. Hundreds of workers were employed loading and offloading turbine parts — with blades the length of a football field — from specially designed ships, some with names drawn from Greek mythology. Local companies also found work supporting the industry, including one that offered water rescue training for people working on construction sites offshore.
Before wind, Passero said that officials tried for years to attract different industries to the pier, which is overshadowed by larger port facilities in New York and Boston. It was often used to import and store large piles of road salt.
The most recent wind project based at the pier is scheduled to finish work next year. Port officials have yet to find a tenant to occupy the space.
“They’ll be back to the old days of trying to lure cargo here,” Passero said.
Amid Trump’s war on wind, a frontline of union and nonunion workers watches opportunity disappear. One project alone, Vineyard Wind, directly employed a total of more than 3,700 full- and part-time workers — most of them from Massachusetts — over eight years of development and construction, according to the developer.
During peak construction activity, as many as 300 union members worked onshore in southeastern Massachusetts for the project, the first large offshore wind farm fully permitted by the federal government. The wind farm was completed this year.
Longshoreman Onix Vazquez, 34, worked full-time tying up barges and moving turbine components on and off New Bedford’s wind pier. He grew up a few blocks away and said he had struggled to find lucrative work until Vineyard Wind began hiring from his union.
Vazquez’s hourly wage of $50 was nearly double what he previously earned unloading occasional shipments of tangerines and juice concentrate. It allowed him and other members of his historically Black union to make down payments on houses, pay off medical bills and for the first time take their families on out-of-state vacations.
“Most of us have to get other jobs for now or collect unemployment,” said Kevin Rose, president of New Bedford’s longshoremen union, which put about two dozen members to work on the project.
The union had been planning to rebuild its nearby meeting hall, which was demolished a decade earlier when work grew scarce. But the next developer to lease New Bedford’s wind pier has delayed its project indefinitely. The union members have put the plans for their new hall on hold.
Vazquez said he now works a seasonal job in the cranberry industry for much lower pay.
“They don’t see that it affects us, the ones that work the projects,” he said.
In response to questions about the impact of the administration’s actions on American offshore wind workers, a spokesperson for the U.S. Department of the Interior repeated criticisms of offshore wind as an expensive and unreliable source of energy.
“The reality is that the Biden administration lured companies into these projects with the promise of millions of taxpayer dollars in subsidies to make these offshore wind projects viable,” the spokesperson said in an email.
The view is more nuanced on the ground. New Bedford’s fishing industry is generally critical of wind farm development because fishermen worry about disruption to fishing grounds.
But fishing catch limits keep boats tied to docks for much of the year. Work for wind farms gets them out to sea and helps pay the bills.
Over the past few years of construction, Vineyard Wind paid about $11 million to 55 fishing vessels from New England and an estimated 60 to 70 fishermen, according to the developer. (The figure also covers fuel.) The fishermen look out for protected species, guard exposed underwater cable as it’s being laid and log information for the developer.
Some fishermen say they will work in offshore wind for as long as they can.
“The scallop boats need the extra revenue,” said Patrick Walsh, 37, a fifth-generation fisherman who plans to rejoin his father’s fishing business when wind work wraps up. “The worst thing for a boat is to sit. Those boats are made to work.”
Wind farm work made it possible for him to buy his first house, he said.
“Fishing would pay bills, and wind was going in the bank.”
Stanley Black & Decker is getting at least $298 million in tariff refunds. The parent firm of TJ Maxx received $331 million. Both companies, and others, are using the money for corporate bonuses instead of repaying shoppers.
When Stanley Black & Decker, one of the world’s largest tool companies, got hit with President Donald Trump’s tariffs last year, the firm made clear that it would be sharing the pain with its customers.
The Connecticut-based company raised prices again and again, moves its executives said were necessary because of the new fees on imports.
Now, after the Supreme Court struck down Trump’s most sweeping tariffs earlier this year, the company is getting at least $298 million refunded. Instead of sharing that bounty with its customers, however, the firm has chosen different recipients:
Its own leaders.
The company is one of at least nine that have disclosed that they are using their refunds not to pay back the cash-strapped consumers who generally covered much of the tariff costs through higher prices, but to give bonuses, according to a ProPublica analysis of thousands of securities filings and earnings calls for publicly traded companies.
Other recognizable companies include the owners of discount department stores TJ Maxx and Marshalls and the golf equipment brand Titleist.
Dozens of other firms have said little about how they plan to use the money other than to characterize the windfall as the kind of earnings they use to determine executive bonuses.
The Trump administration has not publicly detailed which companies are getting the roughly $170 billion in refunds or how much they’ve asked for, and it has denied ProPublica’s requests for this information. But reporters found some of these details while reviewing the disclosures of thousands of publicly traded companies.
Some have described vague plans to pay the money forward by, for example, “returning tariff refunds to our members through pricing,” though they generally don’t say whether that involves price cuts or limiting future increases. Others are paying back businesses they sold products to because they had itemized receipts that detailed the tariff markups.
But consumers hoping for refunds appear to be largely out of luck. With the help of artificial intelligence, ProPublica identified companies that said they planned to refund customers with their tariff windfalls. Almost all of them deal with other businesses, not consumers.
“Executive bonuses are probably the least just way to use this money because it wasn’t anything the executives did that they should be rewarded for. It was a government mistake that resulted in a refund,” said Gregory Germain, a corporate law professor at Syracuse University. “It really explains why it’s so important for the government, when they’re doing something like this, to think it through to make sure consumers don’t pay extra money and not get it back.”
The chain reaction that led to these bonuses began in the first months of Trump’s second term. In February 2025, Trump declared a national emergency over illegal drugs coming in across the border and unilaterally announced new tariffs on goods from the countries he deemed responsible: Canada, Mexico and China.
Then, in April, he declared a second national emergency, this one over the U.S. trade deficit — the fact that the U.S. was importing more than it exported. Declaring it “Liberation Day,” Trump unveiled a poster in the Rose Garden detailing his most sweeping tariffs yet on goods from more than 100 countries.
“Executive bonuses are probably the least just way to use this money.”
Gregory Germain, corporate law professor at Syracuse University
Those tariffs remained in place, with some tweaks, until earlier this year when the Supreme Court struck them down, ruling that Trump had needed congressional approval to impose them.
That left the federal government scrambling to figure out how to refund billions in duties it had collected over the prior year on more than 53 million imported shipments. U.S. Customs and Border Protection set up an online application system. But only the direct payers of the tariffs — called the “importers of record” — are eligible to apply, not the businesses and consumers who took a hit downstream.
The administration and Congress have not placed constraints on how companies use the tariff refunds, though there have been calls to do so. After the Supreme Court ruling, a group of Democratic senators wrote to the president, asking if he would require companies to pass along part of their payments to consumers and assign penalties to those that did not. Doing otherwise, said Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker and Peter Welch, would render the refunds “a giveaway to giant corporations that amounts to theft from the middle class.”
Though Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has denied that the tariffs resulted in significantly higher prices, he has acknowledged the fundamental unfairness of only importers of record getting the refund. “I got a feeling the American people won’t see it,” he said in February at an Economic Club of Dallas event.
Bessent has made the argument that it’s the Democrats who challenged the tariffs in court, not the administration that imposed the tariffs, who are responsible for the transfer of wealth from American consumers to companies.
“The Democratic attorney generals who filed a ridiculous lawsuit against this administration wanted the money to go back to the payer of record,” he said at a press conference. “If I hear another Democratic legislator make the inane remark, ‘The American people should get the money’ — the American people had the money in the U.S. Treasury and we were forced to give it back.”
I got a feeling the American people won’t see” the refund money.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
In some cases, companies have said that they will be splitting at least some of their refund checks with their customers. ProPublica’s analysis shows these companies’ customers are generally other businesses, not average consumers. Among them is Varex Imaging Corp. in Utah, which sells X-ray imaging components for medical businesses and cargo screeners. Varex and firms like it have not elaborated on why they are passing along refunds, but trade experts suspect these business-to-business vendors have detailed contracts that itemize tariff costs.
Shipping companies, like UPS and FedEx, have set up online portals for customers seeking refunds. Though the firms are technically importers of record, they imported goods on behalf of businesses and individuals that paid them to ship products. The companies are itemizing how much customers paid in tariffs and reimbursing them.
A series of lawsuits are attempting to force companies that sell directly to consumers to share some of their refunds. Dozens of firms have been sued, including big-box stores Walmart and Target and apparel companies such as Nike and Lululemon. Apparel and leather costs were some of the hardest hit by Trump’s tariffs. Legal analysts have cast doubt on whether these lawsuits will succeed, though some trade experts have speculated that businesses that used the tariffs as cover to raise prices more than they needed to might settle to avoid embarrassing disclosures.
One of the companies facing a lawsuit is Stanley Black & Decker, the toolmaker that ProPublica found was using some of its refund on bonuses. The named plaintiff is a Wisconsin resident who bought a handheld blower, an impact wrench, a hedge trimmer and other tools from the company last year, but the lawsuit seeks to represent thousands of other customers as well.
“Unless restrained by this Court,” the complaint reads, the company “stands to recover the same tariff payments twice — once from consumers through tariff-inflated prices and again from the federal government through tariff refunds.”
On multiple occasions, the company has acknowledged publicly that it was raising prices because of the tariffs.
The month before the November 2024 election, as Trump was campaigning on dramatic new tariffs, the toolmaker’s then-CEO, Donald Allan Jr., told shareholders that Stanley Black & Decker was preparing for the possibility. “Obviously, coming out of the gate, there would be price increases associated with tariffs that we put into the market,” he said during an earnings call. Then, a few months after Trump unveiled his tariffs, Allan said his team was “remaining focused on executing our robust plan designed to mitigate tariffs” that he said included “targeted pricing actions to improve our gross margin.” Later that year, his successor as chief executive, Chris Nelson, described more price hikes: “We are implementing a second price increase during the fourth quarter to maintain our innovation and brand investments, given the pressures resulting from tariff-related cost increases.”
In its more recent disclosures, the company has been vague about how much of its refund was going to executives, simply saying that some of that gain “was partially offset by directly attributable costs for variable incentive compensation.” “Incentive compensation” is a term the toolmaker uses to describe bonuses.
The company has not responded to the allegations in the lawsuit brought by the Wisconsin resident and did not answer ProPublica’s questions about who is getting paid the bonuses, how much they’re worth and whether customers should be reimbursed.
Securities experts who reviewed the disclosures for ProPublica said it appeared the windfall boosted the company’s profits, which factor into formulas that help determine bonus pay for executives and other employees.
“It wasn’t the executive that triggered that extra profit, so why should their compensation go up?” Germain, the corporate law professor said. “This is one of many examples where these formulas don’t do what they should do.”
The company’s leaders, securities experts said, could have given money back to consumers or lowered prices. Retail giant Burlington Stores, formerly known as Burlington Coat Factory, appears to have done just that.
CEO Michael O’Sullivan recently said the company got $55 million in tariff refunds and “rather than taking a one-time boost to earnings” the company plans “to deliver even sharper values to our shoppers,”
“Over the last few years, the rising cost of living has made life difficult for many customers,” O’Sullivan said, adding that the coming discounts meant investors should expect the “direct impact of tariff refunds to be neutral.”
A company spokesperson confirmed to ProPublica that none of its tariff refund will be going to bonuses.
Not so for other companies.
Acushnet, the Massachusetts golf equipment company that includes the brand Titleist, disclosed an “incentive compensation expense of approximately $12.0 million” out of its refund. Acushnet declined to respond to questions from ProPublica.
TJX, the Massachusetts parent company of TJ Maxx and Marshalls, said it got back $331 million, but as a result, it “accrued incremental expenses of $112 million for year-end incentive compensation and discretionary bonuses for eligible Associates globally.”
The company declined to answer questions from ProPublica about how far down the chain of command the bonuses would go and how much of them would be reserved for top managers. “Given that this is an accrual, and we have not reached the end of our current fiscal year, we have not disclosed any breakout beyond this,” a spokesperson said. The company also declined to say whether it would lower prices or pay back customers with the rest of its refund, saying only that “the remaining amount will be used to support our future growth.”
ProPublica’s examination of tariff refunds was limited to publicly traded companies, which are required to disclose detailed financial information. None of the companies that said they are using the money for bonuses have ever said they planned to refund customers. How private companies are using their refunds is unclear because they aren’t normally required to disclose such information.
Nick Guest, an accounting professor at Cornell University who has studied executive compensation, said the argument for granting leaders bonuses based on the tariff refunds could go both ways.
“If they were penalized for something out of their control,” he said, referring to earnings hits caused by Trump’s tariffs last year, rewarding them now “seems reasonable.”
“But you could say the same thing about customers. If they were penalized, then is it reasonable that they’re not getting rewarded now?” Guest asked. The companies, he said, are “not obligated to give refunds or reduce prices, but doing so could certainly build goodwill with customers.”
President Donald Trump is again facing pressure over his Commerce secretary and longtime friend Howard Lutnick as the department and its leaders face mounting bipartisan criticism in the wake of the Nvidia scandal, according to multiple current and former officials.
And he’s facing criticism from within the administration, too, for a close relationship with Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang they say resulted in lax oversight of the chipmaker. Huang resigned amid the scandal.
Seven current and former administration officials said that the seriousness of the allegations makes this episode substantially different from past efforts to undermine Lutnick. But even some who believe the controversy should cost Lutnick his job are skeptical Trump will turn against his longtime friend, given the president’s own involvement in decisions about chip exports to China. The officials were granted anonymity to speak candidly about private conversations and assessments.
“I don’t know if this is necessarily the straw that’s going to break the camel’s back,” said an administration official with knowledge of the relationship between Lutnick and Trump. “POTUS himself was just too directly involved for this to be an easy, ‘Lutnick is the scapegoat.’”
The scrutiny around Nvidia has escalated far beyond the tech company, roping in the Trump administration just days after Republicans were wiped out during the midterms in part because of the nationwide data center buildout driven by the AI boom. Lutnick’s critics — including GOP lawmakers and other China hawks in the administration — are homing in on his laissez-faire approach to tech, and Lutnick’s fate has major implications for the administration’s broader AI policy.
“This situation is a complete and utter disaster and perfectly encapsulates the last one-and-a-half years of working with Commerce,” said another senior administration official.
At the center of the controversy is Megaspeed, a Singapore-based firm that the U.S. government has examined for helping divert Nvidia’s advanced chips to China. Huang reportedly had an affair with a Megaspeed executive suspected of being a Chinese spy. Lutnick reportedly resisted pressure from administration officials to put the company on a U.S. trade blacklist.
“Unfortunately the more we learn, the more concerned I am about the Department of Commerce, Secretary Lutnick defying President Trump’s orders on Blackwell chips, so we need to investigate that,” Sen. Jim Banks, a Republican on the Senate Banking Committee, said in reference to the Nvidia-produced chip. “I’m hoping that Secretary Lutnick will come in and testify before the Banking Committee soon and help us get to the bottom of it.”
Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) said that if Lutnick doesn’t voluntarily testify before lawmakers, he should be subpoenaed.
Trump and Lutnick have known each other for at least three decades, becoming acquainted at charity events around New York City and bonding after the Sept. 11, 2001, attack on the World Trade Center that killed 658 members of Lutnick’s staff at the financial firm Cantor Fitzgerald, including Lutnick’s brother. Trump often runs ideas past Lutnick, and the two have been known to grab ice cream down at Mar-a-Lago.
A White House official described Lutnick as “a champion of President Trump’s America First trade and tariff policies” and said the president “maintains complete confidence in the secretary and his ability to carry out the position as the most transformative Commerce Secretary in modern history.”
Some current and former officials are also looking to Jeffrey Kessler, the Commerce undersecretary for industry and security, as a potential casualty of the scandal.
Kessler, whose office oversees sensitive technology exports, has been at the center of reports that he halted an investigation into Megaspeed after Nvidia intervened. He has long faced criticism for slowing the work of an agency designed to help manage the flow of chips to China. But former officials and people close to the agency stress that his power is limited to Lutnick’s direction. They anticipate he could be a “fall guy” for deep-rooted issues with the department that they argue are the responsibility of the Commerce secretary.
“If there is a fall guy, Kessler makes a lot of sense,” said a former Commerce Department official. “The president and Lutnick are very good friends and have been for years. I don’t think he would take anything out on his friend. I imagine there would not be an issue in making Kessler the issue.”
But several people with knowledge of the department’s operations questioned whether Kessler could reasonably shoulder the blame for decisions that ultimately rested with Lutnick, who they say maintained unusually tight control over his subordinates.
“He doesn’t make any decisions without Lutnick’s expressed written consent,” the official added. “They very much all wait in a line outside Lutnick’s office to talk to him, as if it’s a professor with office hours.”
Others questioned whether Kessler’s departure would help protect Lutnick, given the severity of a scandal that has already brought down a giant of the tech industry and pushed down the stock of one of the world’s most valuable companies by 8 points in just five days.
In a statement, a BIS spokesperson said Lutnick and Kessler “have a strong working relationship, and both are honored to serve under President Trump to his vision to Make America Great Again.”
Minutes before first bell, Penny Núñez-Brandão scanned the crowd outside Glen Cove Elementary School, looking for familiar faces.
“I don’t see any,” the fifth grader told her mom one morning in August. “None of my friends are coming.”
The start of a new school year can be nerve-wracking under any circumstances. But for Penny and thousands of students across the U.S., this academic year brought the added difficulty of adjusting to an entirely new school after their previous ones shuttered. As U.S. birth rates continue a multidecade slide and state and federal education funding dries up, an increasing number of cash-strapped school districts around the country have resorted to closing campuses to save money.
A total of 1,156 schools closed during the last academic year — the highest number since the pandemic, according to an analysis of federal data by Big Local News at Stanford University. At the same time, new research shows student enrollment has fallen much faster than schools are closing, suggesting more painful financial choices lie ahead.
The Vallejo City Unified School District, a working-class district near San Francisco, serves half as many students as it did two decades earlier. District leaders have closed five campuses since 2025 — a quarter of its schools. They’ve also placed up to a third of all staff positions on the chopping block to help plug a staggering $36 million deficit.
Still, research shows closing schools rarely yields the financial relief districts hope for. Busing students to their reassigned schools, severance for pink-slipped staff and security for empty facilities often eat up any savings. School closures can also set students back academically and make it harder to attract teachers, who may worry the jobs aren’t stable.
Closing schools can also trigger a downward spiral, as frustrated families flee to charter or private schools or other districts. In Vallejo, some parents said they chose to homeschool this fall or were planning to sell their homes and move to neighboring districts.
“Families are literally packing up their kids and moving away,” said Penny’s mother, Kimberly Núñez-Brandão, who already moved her older son to a competing charter school. She recently attended Glen Cove’s curriculum night for families and shared her shock at learning Penny’s new teacher had 32 students in his first class.
“They already overwhelmed teachers with 30-plus students,” she said. “Who’s winning here?”
Fewer births, immigration crackdown and vouchers shrink school enrollment
Rubén Aurelio, superintendent for Vallejo schools, acknowledged cuts and closures can be hard for families but said they are necessary to correct for school districts and budgets designed for a different reality.
“We’re not just closing schools to close schools,” Aurelio said. “We’re right-sizing a district that was built for significantly more kids. And if we’re going to actually improve outcomes for the kids we still have, we need to concentrate resources.”
Nationwide, public school enrollment fell by more than 1.4 million students, roughly 3%, between fall 2019 and 2024, according to an Associated Press analysis of federal education data collected by Stanford University economist Thomas Dee and sociologist Jaymes Pyne. The total number of schools has declined, too — but only to about pre-pandemic levels, the researchers found, suggesting closures are lagging enrollment declines.
Lower birth rates are the primary reason for enrollment decline, but a federal crackdown on immigration and the post-pandemic expansion of private school vouchers and homeschool options have contributed to the decline. Bellwether and WestEd, two research groups, recently estimated declining enrollment could cause schools to lose $11.5 billion in state revenue annually by 2030-2031, potentially prompting widespread layoffs, cuts to academic programs and school closures.
In Vallejo, a city still struggling to bounce back from the closure of a naval base in the 1990s, enrollment has tumbled from nearly 18,000 in the fall of 2006 to about 9,300, according to the district. California has recorded one of the nation’s most precipitous enrollment drops. But school districts throughout the country, including large systems in Cleveland, Houston and Philadelphia, are facing similar closures.
The enrollment and financial situation is unlikely to improve, said Lydia Rainey, research principal at the Center on Reinventing Public Education.
“That’s extremely wishful thinking,” she said. “States aren’t about to open the coffers and swoop in with additional funds to save schools.”
Districts cut costs while trying to keep families
The Vallejo school district is no stranger to budget crises.
In the early 2000s, mismanagement brought Vallejo to the brink of bankruptcy. The state stepped in with a $60 million emergency bailout, which saved Vallejo’s schools from complete financial collapse but kept the district under state oversight until summer 2024. Around the time the state lifted the financial receivership, Aurelio took the helm as superintendent and soon recognized a new set of budget problems.
The district paid for staff salaries using COVID-19 relief money, one-time funding that evaporated early last year. Meanwhile, enrollment dipped below 10,000 students for the first time and was projected to fall further. Vallejo schools, on average, were only 46% full, the district says. Rising inflation and contractual pay hikes further strained the budget.
Aurelio and his team wasted no time in sharing the bad news with families. “I don’t think I ever said, ‘If we close schools.’ I started by saying, ‘When we close,’” he recalled.
In early 2025, the superintendent announced two rounds of closures: The first shuttered two K-8 schools at the end of that academic year. The school board also cut payroll and relocated a district-sponsored charter school to a vacated campus.
Aurelio also set a December 2025 deadline for the board to select three neighborhood schools to close in the second round and approve additional staff cuts.
School closures risk driving more families away
The tumult has left families wondering about their future in the district.
Caitlin Jackson and her husband, a facilities manager, moved to Vallejo with their toddler son, John, for the relatively affordable homes. But large class sizes and safety concerns dissuaded the new parents from enrolling John in a neighborhood school.
They’re taking a chance on the district-sponsored charter — for now.
“Trying to downsize a system while also trying to sustain it, that is just very difficult,” said Jackson. She said she hasn’t ruled out private school or homeschooling.
The sentiment reflects a real risk for districts that choose to close schools. The already painful cost-cutting measure may push even more families into competing charter networks, neighboring districts or private alternatives — further eroding the funding schools get per enrolled student.
So along with cutting budgets, Vallejo is renovating older campuses, hoping to draw younger parents who can’t afford to start a family in San Francisco. (That new spending has rankled some parents, including Núñez-Brandão.) The superintendent said he also plans to open a Tagalog-language school soon, targeting Filipino families from across the Bay Area.
The district has taken more aggressive steps to preserve its enrollment, too. It’s denied some requests from Vallejo families trying to transfer out. (Permission is required under state law.) It has also tried to preempt families’ departures by adding in-demand classes and offering tours of its remaining schools to showcase academic programs or extracurriculars they might have missed.
Jason Willis, a school finance expert with WestEd who has studied campus closures in the Bay Area, credited Vallejo for spreading the cuts and closures over several years and trying to show parents what Vallejo can offer. He likened the approach to the marketing that charter schools have long used to enroll students.
In its second wave of closures, earlier this year, the district shuttered three of its 10 elementary schools. A facilities committee will eventually decide what to do with the vacant campuses, but for now they are vulnerable to burglaries, forcing the district to spend more on security, said Marin Trujillo Cuevas, the district’s executive director for operations.
Students face crowded classrooms and lasting disruption
Inside the classrooms receiving extra students that first week of school, the logistical strain showed.
Ellen Baker-Valdez, a third grade teacher at Glen Cove, had 34 children assigned to her classroom. She’d jammed desks tightly together, their backpacks and lunch boxes piled in a rolling bin by the door.
Outside another classroom, a mother cornered Aurelio, demanding to know why her son’s disability records hadn’t followed him to his new school. The child’s teacher — a substitute, like 7% of Vallejo’s teachers that first day — struggled to answer her questions and attend to the many crying students in her class.
Marisa de la Torre, a managing director of the UChicago Consortium on School Research, said instability created by school closures may last for a while. Studies from the University of Chicago show that academically, displaced students often suffer long-term drops in reading and math. That’s especially true when students end up at low-performing schools.
“It takes a while to recover, if they recover at all,” she said.
Núñez-Brandão isn’t sure she wants to stick around long enough to find out.
Five years ago, as her son prepared for his fifth grade year at Glen Cove, the district reassigned him along with Penny — then a kindergartner — to Highland Elementary due to scheduling difficulties during the pandemic.
“They’re doing it all over again,” Núñez-Brandão said of her daughter’s experience this year. “And I can promise you: More schools are going to close.”
Weeks into the new school year, Penny still struggled with the transition to Glen Cove. She started to make new friends and said she feels comfortable on campus. She also liked her teacher, a first-year educator who’d joined Vallejo’s teacher residency program, launched last year to attract new educators and improve retention.
But with 32 kids in the class, she said it’s hard to concentrate.
And then, on a Tuesday in October, Núñez-Brandão received a note in the Glen Cove parent portal: Penny’s teacher resigned, effective immediately. The school will rely on a long-term substitute for now, the district said.
That night, Núñez-Brandão decided to call a competing charter school in Vallejo — a campus she and Penny already toured — and ask if they still have room for her daughter.
A healthy person farts about 14 to 20 times each day. All together, that’s enough gas to fill a super stinky party balloon.
Farts are made of gases that are produced by trillions of tiny organisms called microbes, mostly bacteria, that live in your gut. These organisms have an important job: They help chew up food that your stomach cannot break down on its own. In the process, they act like mini chemical factories that provide you with nutrients while releasing waste gases into your gut. These gases mix with air you swallow and other gases that you make during digestion. After passing through the intestines, they come out in bursts as farts.
Anywhere from 20% to 90% of a fart’s volume consists of nitrogen, which makes up more than three quarters of air. Up to 10% of a fart is oxygen, which humans need in order to breathe. Up to 30% is carbon dioxide, up to 50% is hydrogen, and up to 10% is methane. Microbes produce most of the carbon dioxide, hydrogen and methane, though some of the carbon dioxide is made when digestive juices mix with stomach acid.
But wait: These are not the gases that give farts their delightful array of aromas. What makes farts so malodorous is other gas molecules that contain the element sulfur. Pure sulfur has no smell on its own, but when combined with other elements it makes molecules that reek.
One key culprit is hydrogen sulfide, which is famous for smelling like rotten eggs. Others include methanethiol, which has a bouquet of cabbage, sewage or skunk spray, and dimethyl sulfide, which hits the nostrils with scents of cooked corn, algae or seafood.
Only tiny amounts are required: One molecule of hydrogen sulfide among 1 million other gas molecules has enough power to do the job. That’s equivalent to one kernel of corn in a truckload of about 1,250 ears, or 10 bricks out of all the bricks that make up the Empire State Building in New York City. Other sulfur-containing gasses can be sniffed out at even more minuscule amounts.
Food is a key source of amino acids, nutrients that build proteins the body needs to function and grow. Two amino acids, methionine and cysteine, contain sulfur, and they are plentiful in meat, dairy, eggs, and to a lesser degree, beans and grains. Some foods – most notably, vegetables such as cabbage, broccoli, Brussels sprouts and cauliflower – contain other molecules that also have sulfur in them.
As you might know from experience, it’s impossible to hold in a fart until it goes away. It will come out somehow – sometimes at speeds up to 10 feet per second, according to back-of-the-envelope estimates, including my own. This rush of gas exiting the body makes the surrounding tissue vibrate, often causing an embarrassing noise.
But sometimes this natural body process can be a real bummer – like on an airplane. Cabin pressure in flight is often lower than normal air pressure on the ground, which can cause the gas in your gut to expand, spurring more farts. To protect the noses of travelers trapped together in the friendly skies, researchers designed seat cushions and blankets that contain sulfur-absorbing substances, such as activated charcoal. So far, no airlines have adopted these funk-reducing technologies, but you can buy them yourself.
Despite farts’ assault on the senses, your ability to detect them means your nose is doing exactly what evolution designed it to do: act as a chemical sensor for sulfur-containing gases. People can detect hydrogen sulfide and methanethiol at minuscule concentrations, even when there is less than one molecule of these compounds amid billions of other molecules.
These smells can signal the presence of rotting substances and bacterial activity that might harbor pathogens that can make you sick, or deadly environments such as swamps, stagnant caves and volcano vents that can suffocate and kill you.
So the next time you lay a fart that’s pungent enough to clear the room, don’t apologize – just say you’re conducting a live demonstration of natural chemistry that took eons of evolution to perfect.
DHS made a record buy of the FN303, a launcher with a 23-year trail of harm.
This story is published in partnership with the Human Rights Center at the University of California Berkeley.
On the evening of March 28, 2026, USC freshman Tucker Collins was attending a No Kings protest outside the Metropolitan Detention Center in downtown Los Angeles when he suddenly collapsed, screaming and clutching his right eye. Initially, amidst the drums, shouts, and flags, only a few people noticed the young man with long blond hair go down, but as he was pulled to the curb by on-scene independent field medics, it quickly became clear that something was very wrong: he had been shot in the face by an officer monitoring the protests, and his eyeball was completely ruptured.
At the hospital, doctors removed jagged plastic fragments and metal shards from Collins’ eye socket. “When eventually we got to the hospital, and they told me, ‘We’re gonna have to remove your eye,’ I didn’t really know how to process it,” recalled Collins, an aspiring filmmaker. “I understood intimately that this is something that could happen. This is why I was there—to document these sorts of things happening.”
Video of the incident quickly circulated online, and one theory was that Collins had been blinded by a PepperBall round, fired from somewhere in the MDC. This turned out to be incorrect. The plastic fragments and small metal pellets doctors removed were actually fired from a lesser-known and more powerful weapon, the Fabrique Nationale 303 Less Lethal Launcher, or FN303.
A report produced by the Human Rights Center at UC Berkeley and Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) reveals that the FN303 has been disproportionately responsible for some of the most severe injuries in recent immigration-related protests across the US. The report, titled “Charting the Crackdown,” used open-source methodologies to trace and document misuses of crowd control weapons at immigration related protests from June 2025 through May 2026. The researchers catalogued over 400 incidents of misuse, the vast majority of which were committed by Federal agents.
A peculiar pattern was hidden in the data: although the FN303 makes up only 12 of the 412 total cases of misuse (less than three percent) it was responsible for some of the grisliest and most debilitating injuries documented in the study. In fact, the FN303 was responsible for a higher proportion of severe injuries than those from any other single weapon. The report’s lead author, Dr. Rohini Haar, who is an emergency room doctor and an expert on crowd-control weapons, considered the discovery something of a surprise.“The FN303 is a unique example of something we were not looking for,” she said. “To be honest, even I didn’t know what an FN303 was.”
The FN303 has caused over half a dozen serious injuries between June 2025 and May 2026. But its history of severe, sometimes deadly injuries spans the launcher’s entire 23- year history. When asked about this pattern, Henry de Harenne, Head of Communications at FN Herstal declined to offer details saying that “the review of specific incidents is a matter for the agencies concerned and the competent authorities.”
Federal agencies have invested unprecedented amounts of funds in the FN303 in recent months; the Department of Homeland Security is the largest purchaser of the launcher in the Federal government. Though it’s unclear how much they paid per unit, local law enforcement records from California show launchers selling for $800 each, and according to government contracts, DHS has bought $2.2 million in weapons and projectiles since 2021 alone. The agency’s largest purchase, however, came in September 2025, during Operation Midway Blitz in Chicago, when they purchased more than $1 million of FN303 launchers and projectiles.
Marketed as highly safe and very accurate, this .68 caliber pneumatic launcher has been used by law enforcement agencies all over the world— from Belgium and Turkey, to Georgia and even Libya under Muammar Gaddafi, whose ministry of defense purchased 2000 launchers in 2009. Though it closely resembles a pepperball or paintball gun, with a plastic body and air tank affixed to the front, it fires a denser and faster-moving projectile that can cause debilitating injuries in crowd control settings. In some countries, Belgium and Georgia, for instance, deployments of the launcher have triggered national debates about its use in managing protests. But in the US, the FN303 has gone largely unnoticed, even as demonstrators continue to be injured. With the Trump administration pouring nearly $70 billion into the Department of Homeland Security through the 2029 fiscal year, the agency made the federal government’s single largest purchase on record of the weapon in September 2025—just as protests peaked across the country.
In 2003, within months of the FN303’s release by Belgian weapons manufacturer FN Herstal, the seriousness of the injuries it inflicts became controversial. On March 29, during protests against the World Trade Organization in Geneva, Switzerland, Swiss police shot union organizer Denise Chervet in the temple with an FN303. She was hospitalized with metal pellets embedded dangerously close to nerve clusters in her face. Fearing permanent paralysis, her doctors refused to operate. Chervet would live with the remnant shards for the rest of her life.
The incident caused an uproar in Switzerland. An investigation conducted by the Council of State of Geneva found that officers had little training on how to safely deploy the FN303 prior to using it, and the cantons of Geneva and Zurich both immediately discontinued its use. A review of Swiss cantonal police agency data reveals that no law enforcement agency in Switzerland that deploys the FN303.
Chervet may have been the first to experience this weapon, but she was far from the last. A little over a year later, on October 21, 2004, celebrations turned to chaos in Boston after the Red Sox defeated the New York Yankees in the ALCS Championship. A responding officer, wielding the FN303, shot and killed Victoria Snelgrove, a 21-year-old journalism student. The investigation into Snelgrove’s death found that the department failed to properly train its officers in the safe deployment of the weapon. According to the report, Police Deputy Superintendent Robert O’Toole gave an FN303 to an officer who had not been trained or authorized to use it, saying, “Just pull the trigger.” In short, the investigation found that the department had misinterpreted FN Herstal’s claims about the weapon’s ability to penetrate the skin.
“The FN303 appeared to have been viewed by the Department to be not simply ‘less- lethal,’ but really non-lethal,” the report notes. “The fact that the rounds are advertised by the manufacturer as never causing a ‘perforation of the skin,’ which proved to be inaccurate, may have contributed to this misunderstanding.”
On the night of Snelgrove’s death, Boston police officers shot two other people in the head with FN303s in Fenway Park, injuring them and causing them to bleed from the face.
“It does not appear that the police immediately understood that these injuries were the result of FN303 projectiles. If they had, it would have alerted the police that there was a problem with the use of (the) FN303.”
“It does not appear that the police immediately understood that these injuries were the result of FN303 projectiles,” reads the report. “If they had, it would have alerted the police that there was a problem with the use of (the) FN303.”
Once the broader investigation was completed, which revealed that the weapon was far more dangerous than the department had been led to believe, Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis ordered the FN303s destroyed.
Both Chervet’s injury and Snelgrove’s death sparked immediate and widespread reporting, but over two decades later, the FN303 remains largely unknown in the US. Recent reports of injuries involving FN303s frequently cite “rubber bullets” or the general category of “less lethal projectiles” as the culprit. American law enforcement often uses the weapon in much the same way as they would a PepperBall launcher. “PepperBall’s got certain ways that they build and assemble their delivery system versus FN,” says Thor Eells, executive director of the National Tactical Officers Association (NTOA), a nonprofit that trains over 14,000 law enforcement officers a year. “But at the end of the day, they are very, very similar in what type of ammunition they deliver.”
Alexandre Papy PhD, a lieutenant colonel and the Head of the Weapon Systems and Ballistics Department at the Belgian Royal Military Academy, says this comparison is understandable, but incomplete. “They are both expelling projectiles, impacting projectiles,” he explains, “but the magnitude is quite different.” This is because PepperBall rounds are simple plastic spheres filled with chemical irritants or marking paint. On the other hand, the FN303’s ammunition is composed of hard, transparent plastic, filled with bismuth pellets in a semi-spherical dome, with a cylindrical finned design in the back to stabilize the trajectory.
The theory behind this unusual design is that, upon impact, the round would break open and spread the heavy bismuth across a larger surface area, thus distributing the force of the projectile. Video materials marketing the launcher claim this feature gives the weapon system “sufficient energy to gain compliance from a suspect with minimal risk of skin penetration.”
Researchers like Papy stand by these claims. He views the FN303’s shattering projectile as extremely effective at preventing penetrative injury, even calling it “quite safe.” He does cite one major caveat. “If the projectile reaches the head, you have a problem,” he says. The reason for this, Dr. Haar of PHR explains, is that because there is less fat and tissue to absorb impact on the head or face, the debris of hard plastic and bismuth from the shattering projectile have a much higher chance of penetrating. “Any projectile with metal or anything composite with metal is more harmful,” she says.
FN Herstal said in a statement that all of their documentation and training emphasize that the FN303 should never be aimed at the head or neck. They also mark every unit of the FN303 with a label warning against aiming the weapon above the shoulders.
But even so, shots to the head with impact projectiles continue and data show that the FN303 is particularly problematic in this realm. The “Charting the Crackdown” database logged 73 incidents of head shots across all weapon types. This includes 34 head shots from PepperBall launchers and six from the FN303. Though more common, PepperBall launchers were far less likely to cause penetrative injuries than FN303s. Less than 10 percent of head shots from PepperBalls caused lacerations, while five out of six from the FN303 penetrated the body, causing lacerations and sometimes blindings.
By looking for its unique injury profile of skin penetration coupled with bismuth pellets and plastic shards, researchers at the Human Rights Center identified 16 instances of severe injuries caused by the weapon since 2003. All save one involved a shot to the head. “The fact that two young people are either dead or blind from the same weapon 20 years apart means we failed in identifying this as a risk,” Haar said, underscoring a systemic problem.
In 2020, in the wake of the murder of George Floyd, the FN303 was used by police departments across the country. On May 29, 2020, a Georgia State Trooper using the FN303 shot and permanently disfigured the face of journalism student and filmmaker Mikaela Dyett, who was filming a protest in downtown Atlanta. Like Chervet, Dyett will live with the debris from the round embedded in her face for the rest of her life. During a protest in Portland, Oregon, on June 30, an independent journalist covering it was shot in the groin by an FN303. His injury took over a month to heal. The following month, also in Portland, on July 25, 2020, a mother of three was shot in the forehead with the launcher, causing severe lacerations which required stitches.
A day later, on July 26, Portland-based journalist Trip Jennings was similarly shot. The round punctured the face shield of his gas mask, embedding pellets in his eyeball. Jennings had previously reported in the West Bank, where he had been hit with stun grenades, struck in the leg with a tear gas canister, and shot with pepperballs. “I got hit by all sorts of different munitions in the West Bank, and I can say very conclusively that this was the worst and most painful and longest impact,” Jennings recalled. The force of impact from the FN303 was so intense that he initially thought he had been hit by a shotgun shell.
In many of these cases—such as with Dyett and Jennings—the FN303 was not initially identified as the culprit.
For Scott Reynhout, a researcher who has spent the better part of a decade studying the use of crowd control weapons in protest settings with Physicians for Human Rights, this lack of awareness around the FN303’s potential for severe and even fatal injury is the clearest explanation for why it’s so dangerous.
“I was certainly guilty of failing to understand the nuances of this weapon in the past,” he admits. While working with PHR, he co-authored a study that cataloged injuries to the head and face caused by impact projectiles during the George Floyd protests in 2020. At the time, he made no distinction between this launcher and Pepperball guns. But six years later, in January 2026, as he began compiling a new database of crowd control weapon misuse, again with PHR, he saw a video of a DHS agent shooting 21-year-old Kaden Rummler in the eye at a demonstration in Santa Ana, California. At that point, he realized the FN303 was in a category of its own.
“It was something different, not just the severity of the injury, but also the types of injuries that you’re seeing,” Reynhout says. “If we think about the different types of less lethal weapons, there are a lot of different shapes and sizes, but not a lot of them can actually fit inside the orbit of the eye. Fewer still can fit inside the orbit of the eye and then carry enough energy with it to actually pass through the orbit and affect the brain.”
“I was certainly guilty of failing to understand the nuances of this weapon in the past.”
Now working independently, Reynhout visited the bullet-casing littered ground of Jawbone Canyon to better understand how the launcher works and to collect data on its ballistic qualities. This sun-baked valley located two hours outside of Los Angeles is commonly used as an improvised gun range by recreational shooters in the area. Crucially for Reynhout’s work, it’s a long, narrow canyon where he can set up targets up to 60 meters out without fear of striking passersby. His range consists of large cardboard and plywood targets to evaluate how far the projectiles drop over specific distance and doppler radars strategically placed to measure projectile velocity at the muzzle and at the target.
Reynhout extracts the FN303 from a large case and fires half a dozen rounds at a square of heavy-duty, reinforced plywood. The launcher makes a popping noise with each projectile, followed a split second later by a loud crack as the rounds collide with the wood. Shards of plastic explode outward. Even from 30 meters away, the dents are visible.
Almost immediately, the tests reveal the disparities with the claims made by FN Herstal. In the FN303 Armorer Training Manual from 2002, the only publicly available copy, the weapon is described as firing projectiles at 280-300 feet per second. In Reynhout’s testing, the velocity at the muzzle of the weapon reaches as high as 330 feet per second.
“The formula for kinetic energy is one half mass times velocity squared,” Reynhout says. He explains that in layman’s terms this means that “even small changes in velocity can have an outsize effect on the kinetic energy.” Though the additional 30 feet per second difference he measured versus FN Herstal’s claims represents only a 10 percent increase in projectile velocity, they translate to a 21 percent increase in energy delivered to the target.
More concerning is the fact that the disparity in velocity is not a surprise to Alexandre Papy of the Belgian Royal Military Academy. He says that the FN303 can be tuned to fire at higher velocities and explains that because “it’s compressed air, it’s just a question of changing the pressure threshold.” Law enforcement agencies can even make this request of FN Herstal on an entire order of launchers. Meaning launchers used on the street may well exceed the specifications listed in manufacturer documentation. When asked about the velocity of their own launchers, Customs and Border Protection responded that their internal test showed projectiles traveling at the advertised 280-300 feet per second.
By examining the gap between a point of aim and puncture holes made by the launcher’s projectiles in sheets of cardboard, Reynhout’s testing confirms what is already known, that the FN303 does not fire projectiles in a straight line but in an arcing trajectory. The round initially travels upward, going higher than the point of firing, only dropping as it nears the target. By collecting this data, Reynhout can determine exactly how much officers must adjust their aim at specific distances.
When aiming at a subject 30 meters away, the rounds will hit more or less exactly where intended, which is known as being “zeroed.” Between the 40 and 50 meters, Reynhout found that the rounds start to drop precipitously, requiring the user to aim over a foot higher than the target they had intended to hit. This introduces “a pretty significant hazard that is completely dependent upon the individual who’s firing the weapon’s ability to accurately judge distance,” Reynhout notes. “Even if a police officer is doing their due diligence…there’s still the possibility that these weapons could go errant and therefore strike someone in a place where they should not be struck.”
Because it is a specialty weapon, proper use of the FN303 is not typically taught in general use-of-force training. Instead, law enforcement agencies can request an instructor certification course from FN Herstal. Once certified, these instructors then bring lessons learned back to their departments. Police insiders have noted that this is part and parcel of the specialty less lethal weapons industry.
According to police training practitioners and use of force experts, these manufacturer-led, weapons-specific trainings typically focus on how to assemble, operate, and repair the weapon. Issues around tactics, use of force standards, and procedure are considered to be matters of internal department policy for individual agencies to manage independently. According to a statement from FN Herstal, the manufacturer “provides equipment, training and technical support but does not determine operational policies, rules of engagement or use-of-force doctrines.”
When asked for details about their training program, FN Herstal stated that though their curriculum covers “deployment procedures, engagement distances and target selection, including repeated instructions on the areas that must not be targeted,” namely the head and neck, “operators remain bound by their agency’s use-of-force policy.”
“(Manufacturers) will sometimes offer model policies,” said Roy Taylor, a former police chief and expert witness in use of force cases, “but they will never tell the agency what they should or shouldn’t do. That’s outside their bailiwick.”
“(Manufacturers) will sometimes offer model policies, but they will never tell the agency what they should or shouldn’t do. That’s outside their bailiwick.”
For Thor Eells of the NTOA, the lack of standards in training creates a gap in the landscape for US law enforcement.
“We have this duty to make sure that people are thinkers. So we spend more time on the case law,” said Eells of the NTOA’s approach to training. But on the national level, “There is no standard. None. And in fact, in policing as a whole, there are little or no standards in the United States.”
When it comes to speciality launchers like the FN303, the baseline for training tends to come from the manufacturer. “Unless that specific agency or entity providing the training chooses to go above and beyond,” Eells explained, “then the training tends to be the minimum as put forth by the manufacturer.”
When asked about their training program for the FN303, DHS sent a reply from Customs and Border Protection. The agency stated that CBP agents are required to complete a qualification course and yearly recertification to be authorized to use the launcher. The course includes “classroom instruction, written and practical assessments, familiarization, use of force instruction, and qualification.” Agents are also instructed not to “target the head, neck, spine, or groin unless deadly force is reasonable and necessary.”
The content of FN Herstal’s curriculum is not publicly available. There are state-level institutions, such as the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, known as POST, which is a government agency that sets standards for local law enforcement agencies. It has the power to decertify officers for serious misconduct, and oversees general use of force training curricula. Nonetheless, manufacturer-led specialty weapons trainings lay outside the purview of agencies like POST. Meaning there is virtually no oversight on what manufacturer-trained instructors actually share with their departments.
After measuring the arc, precision, and velocity of the launcher, Reynhout sets up one final test of the FN303’s real power. He removes the cardboard target, now fully dotted with holes, and replaces it with a box of ballistics clay, a polymer clay of a particular consistency that is often used to measure the force of the impact of different weapons. The box is about three inches deep and open on one side. Reynhout explains that though the clay is a poor proxy for the human body, he is able to measure the craters that projectiles leave on its surface to compare the energy that they deliver at any given distance. It’s a “visual representation of the numbers that I’m presenting,” he says.
First, Reynhout takes aim with a paintball gun loaded with rubber balls, the exact size and weight of a standard PepperBall. The force of this shot, he explains, should be roughly equivalent to that of a PepperBall launcher—the weapon that law enforcement consistently conflates with the FN303.
He fires from a distance of about seven meters and hits his target. The small yellow ball makes a nearly one-inch deep indentation, before popping out and bouncing away through the desert.
Reynhout then aims the FN303. The loud pop of the weapon reverberates through the canyon. In an instant, a crater appears in the clay. The round has bored a hole all the way through to the back of the box. Shards of plastic and thousands of bismuth pellets coat the inside of the crater.
This weapon is no PepperBall launcher.
The Los Angeles Police Department frequently has turned to the FN303 when responding to anti-ICE demonstrations. As protests raged last June, sparked by ICE raids in the LA area, LAPD cracked down hard. The department deployed tear gas and fired thousands of rounds from less lethal weapons. Uses of the FN303 peaked in the 8-day period between June 6 and June 14, 2025, when the department reported firing 244 FN303 rounds in response to immigration related protests.
The LAPD periodically releases summarized reports to the public of their use of less lethal weapons and the injuries caused by their activities. These documents noted a total of 12 injuries from their activity during this period, but documentation did not specify which weapons caused these injuries.
By the end of January 2026, the LAPD had shot at least three journalists with the FN303 and seriously injured a woman with the weapon, causing severe lacerations to her face. She is now suing the department. Despite its repeated, sometimes dangerous misuses of the launcher, the LAPD continued its use in February. After a federal judge banned the department from using 40mm impact rounds in January, citing safety concerns, Chief Jim McDonnell announced at a Board of Police Commissioners meeting that the FN303 was an alternative option. The LAPD declined to answer any questions about the number of FN303s the department has in use, or to provide information about their training program for the launcher.
DHS, too, has leaned into the FN303, investing historic amounts in purchases of the weapon in September 2025. The effects of this DHS investment can be seen in the Trump administration’s crackdown on the recent surge of protests. Of the 12 incidents of FN303 misuse identified by the HRC and PHR team this past year, eight were perpetrated by federal agents working for Customs and Border Protection (CBP) or the Federal Protective Service (FPS). Tucker Collins and his attorney, V. James DeSimone, filed a $100 million tort claim as a result of the injury DHS caused. Following the incident, DHS issued a statement denying any wrongdoing.
This surge of FN303 use has resulted in a new wave of injuries, many of which are permanent. Collins was not the only person who was partially blinded by DHS officers wielding the FN303 this year. In January, Kaden Rummler was shot in the eye from roughly three feet away by an FPS agent outside a federal building in Santa Ana. Video of the incident shows agents dragging Rummler across the concrete and into the facility to arrest him, blood pouring down his face. Like Collins, he will never again see out of his left eye.
The Federal Protective Service, the DHS subagency responsible for the injuries to both Collins and Rummler, follows a use of force policy that classifies any impact projectile fired at the neck or head as a use of deadly force. That same policy limits deadly force to extreme circumstances. “An FPS (officer) may use deadly force only when the (officer) has reasonable belief that the subject of such force poses an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm to the (officer) or to another person,” the policy manual states.
The Human Rights Center and Physicians for Human Rights identified five incidents in which people were shot in the head by federal officers using the FN303 over the past year, and one by LAPD. Along with Collins and Rummler, an 84-year-old woman, a 25-year-old woman, and two other unidentified victims suffered injuries of varying degrees after being struck in the head or face by a projectile from an FN303.
Outside of the US, injuries of the same severity were enough to trigger national conversations about whether the FN303 should be permitted at all. In the early 2000s and 2010s, Georgia, Turkey, and Switzerland all saw serious injuries, including blinding from FN303s being used in crowd control settings. The incidents prompted debates, and parliamentary sessions. Beyond the limited uproar following Victoria Snelgrove’s death, the FN303 has never been meaningfully scrutinized in the US.
Recent American use of the FN303 has sparked a new debate in FN Herstal’s home country of Belgium. Members of the right-wing New Flemish Alliance party, such as Defense Minister Theo Francken, have held up the LAPD’s use of the FN303 as aspirational. They argue that the weapon, which is heavily regulated in Belgium and rarely used in crowd control settings, should be deployed more broadly against left-wing protesters.
In October 2025, Francken travelled on a Belgian economic mission to California, where he, along with the CEO of FN Browning Julien Compère, Belgium’s Princess Astrid, and Los Angeles’ Deputy Police Chief Steve Embrich, had attended a demonstration of FN Herstal’s new generation FN303 Tactical at an LAPD firing range. The group was presented not only with an updated model of the launcher but also with an AI camera system mounted to the muzzle that automatically locks the trigger if it detects the user pointing at a face.
Days after his visit to the US, Francken posted to X advocating for use of the FN303 against Belgian protesters, “Extreme-left antifa mobs wrecked the entrance hall of the Immigration Service and injured multiple staff members…The police should deploy the FN303 against this scum, just like the LAPD, the police in Los Angeles, does.”
“The use of FN303 is strictly regulated, and I want to keep it that way. There will be no change in the potential use of this weapon by police in policing protests.”
In Belgium, the use of the FN303 by law enforcement remains limited to special tactical units and is subject to approval from the Minister of the Interior, who is now Bernard Quintin. He has indicated he has no desire to change this anytime soon, telling journalists, “The use of FN303 is strictly regulated, and I want to keep it that way. There will be no change in the potential use of this weapon by police in policing protests.”
Rémy Farge is a researcher for the Belgian Human Rights League, a group that is advocating fiercely against any broader deployment of the FN303. In his opinion, “FN Herstal is making a sort of admission with the release of the ‘FN Smart Protector 303T,’ as if to cynically address the numerous cases of maiming and eye loss that these weapons have already caused.” As he sees it, the comparatively stringent regulations on less lethal weapons in Belgium fall far short of what is necessary. “If we take seriously the danger posed by this weapon,” he said, “then we must stop downplaying its effects and work toward reducing its use, particularly through stricter bans.”
Meanwhile, in the US, the FN303 remains in wide circulation, though it’s unclear exactly how wide. Each department at the municipal, county, state, and federal levels manages its own arsenal of approved weapons. With 18,000 police departments, before counting federal law enforcement agencies, the prospect of stronger standards regulating the use of a single weapon seems unlikely. As Reynhout points out, “The United States is not an ideal place to use the legislative cudgel to manage these weapons.”
For law enforcement, the decision of what to use then becomes a question of risk assessment and mitigation. “There is no magic threshold to say again, now that is lethal, that is non-lethal,” says Papy, “you can kill people with almost anything— including just your hands.”
Despite the established comparison with the Pepperball launcher, there is another weapon that shares features with the FN303 whose history may prove instructive: the beanbag round. Like the FN303’s bismuth-filled ammunition, it is a less lethal projectile filled with metal fragments. In this case, a kevlar sack filled with lead pellets.
These beanbags were used widely during the 2020 George Floyd protests, causing severe injuries by embedding in people’s bodies and cracking skulls. Since then, Reynhout notes, law enforcement has shifted away from using these projectiles, which caused so much harm six years ago. The data support his claim. The database compiled by Physicians for Human Rights and the Berkeley Human Rights Center found only one misuse of a beanbag round in over 400 incidents recorded from June 2025 through May 2026. But the question remains, why?
“To my knowledge, there wasn’t any sort of legislation that specifically targeted beanbag rounds that was passed,” says Reynhout “yet police departments of their own volition seem to have come to the same conclusion that we came to, that the risk is unacceptable.”
That assessment of risk doesn’t come on its own. For Haar of PHR, it comes down to public understanding of the dangers of the use of the FN303. “I think that’s kind of the goal,” she says. “You just got to push against it and increase the cost of buying that.” If that happens, then perhaps the FN303 could quietly go the way of the bean bag.